Payment technology moves fast, and regulation inevitably takes longer to catch up. The challenge is giving businesses enough clarity, while new rules are being developed, to decide where to invest, what to build and how to launch new technology safely. That’s why it’s encouraging that the government plans to give the Bank of England an innovation objective alongside its core responsibility of protecting financial stability.

It will apply to payment systems and emerging forms of digital money within the Bank’s regulatory perimeter. I would like to see the new objective drive an even stronger working relationship between regulators and payment companies as that process develops.

HM Treasury’s National Payments Vision refers to “significant regulatory congestion” across the current payments landscape, with programmes from government, regulators and industry all moving at once. For payment companies, that means keeping a constant eye on rule changes, often involving different bodies, while continuing to build products and solutions for merchants.

Clear rules shape investment decisions

Evidence shows that investors are more likely to back a company when the regulatory position is clearer. A Bank for International Settlements study observed companies that went through the Financial Conduct Authority’s regulatory sandbox and found a 15 per cent increase in capital raised, while the likelihood of raising funding increased by 50 per cent. The researchers linked some of that effect to lower regulatory costs and fewer information gaps.

HM Treasury’s National Payments Vision says regulation should be “clear, predictable and proportionate”. Predictable is the word I would focus on. Payment companies need their north star objective, a clear idea of what they’re working toward and how to do it, before too much time and money is committed. Regulation will evolve as technologies and markets change – and businesses should expect that – but there is a significant difference between adapting to a clearly signposted direction and having to rethink the entire strategy late in the development process.

That predictability becomes even more important when companies are investing in infrastructure that needs to work across multiple merchants, markets, and regulatory requirements.

Industry input should come before a proposal is turned into regulation

Under its new secondary objective, the Bank must report to Parliament each year on what it has done to support innovation. That annual report should become a useful measure of how the relationship between regulation and industry is working. It should show not just how many consultations or roundtables have taken place, but where industry feedback has materially influenced the development of policy. I would want to see where a proposal moved, or remained unchanged, because businesses raised an operational, commercial or technical consequence that needed to be considered.

Consultation should not mean industry gets everything it asks for. Regulators have wider responsibilities, particularly around financial stability and consumer protection. But businesses need the opportunity to explain how proposals will operate once they move from a policy document into a live payment environment. That dialogue is particularly important when the technology itself is evolving quickly.

New technology still has to prove its worth

Merchants and acquirers are making decisions off the back of all this too, even if they never read a Bank of England consultation themselves. In a busy retail store, payment data can feed into fraud checks or financial reconciliation. At a high-end hotel, the transaction may be large, but the customer still expects it to go through quickly. Any new payment method or technology has to fit into everything already happening around those transactions.

Payments used to be judged primarily on whether the transaction went through. That is still fundamental, but the data surrounding a payment has become almost as valuable as processing the transaction itself. It can show a business where customers are dropping out partway through a purchase, where revenue may be going missing, or where an emerging risk deserves closer attention.

A merchant still has to decide whether changing its payment setup is worth the cost and disruption. If new technology fixes a problem the business already has, the case is relatively easy to understand. “It’s new” is a much harder sell, and that’s especially true when the technology has to be introduced across existing payment infrastructure. The customer may only see a new terminal, checkout option or payment method, but behind that can sit changes to integration, data flows, reconciliation and processes. The aim is for all of that work to remain largely invisible to the customer.

Late changes to the rules can make implementation harder. By then, work may already be under way and money committed.

Clear rules also make it clear who is accountable

As more information moves into the payment layer, the boundary between the payment provider and the merchant becomes increasingly important. In retail, for example, transaction data can help identify patterns that suggest fraud, payment failure, or unusual purchasing behaviour. But technology can only surface the information. The merchant still needs to decide what action to take and remain accountable for that decision.

Payment technology can therefore give a business better information without changing where responsibility ultimately sits. That boundary needs to remain clear as new payment models develop. A company can build around a demanding rule when it knows where its responsibility starts and stops. Ambiguity becomes much harder to deal with once the technology is already live.

The Bank of England’s new innovation objective is therefore most useful if it helps create greater visibility earlier in the process. Innovation needs regulation that businesses can understand, plan around and build against with confidence. Building something new is much easier when everyone knows where the boundaries are.

Up next

  1. Trade in times of crisis: Bank of Palestine’s Maram Obeidi on keeping trade movingThe world of trade finance can seem a deceptively orderly one on the pages of a textbook. International commerce operatesArticleCorrespondent BankingJames Dorman18 Nov
  2. In Kenyan trade, paper still has the last wordAn ICC Kenya survey of 48 organisations finds firms have invested in digital systems, yet 94 per cent had aArticleDigital TradeTim Staheli17 Nov
  3. UK payment directive: A wake-up call for corporate treasurersIf you’ve talked about the UK Payment Directive – the payment terms embodied in the new Commercial Payments Bill –ArticlePaymentsTimothy Rose17 Nov

Stay Ahead of the Curve

Get exclusive insights, expert analysis, and breaking news on liquidity and risk management, delivered to your inbox