An ICC Kenya survey of 48 organisations finds firms have invested in digital systems, yet 94 per cent had a shipment or its financing held up in the past year while they waited for a paper original.

A cut rose does not keep, which is why Kenya’s growers fly their crop to market and why the sector watches air freight charges so closely. Roses make up about 69 per cent of Kenya’s flower exports, according to the Agriculture and Food Authority, and the flowers reach 143 destinations. The paperwork that travels with them is more old-fashioned. Flower exporters told a new ICC Kenya survey that they still need signed or stamped originals for nearly every one of the eight common trade documents it asked about, more than any other sub-sector.

The report, Advancing Digital Trade and Trade Finance in Kenya, was published in September 2026 by ICC Kenya with BTC Group. Its authors surveyed 48 organisations in six sectors, from exporters and manufacturers to banks and insurers, of which 26 were large firms, 17 medium-sized and five small.

The central finding would fit on a customs form. Most firms told the survey that their own systems are largely ready. They said what holds them up is the paper originals still required by banks, port and border agencies, and the law. In the past year, 94 per cent had a shipment’s movement, release or financing delayed while they waited for an original paper document, and 38 per cent said this happens frequently. Some 65 per cent still need a paper original “usually” or “always” to prove ownership, release cargo or pledge goods. Delays rise with dependence on paper: 71 per cent of firms that always need an original said they are frequently held up, against 13 per cent of those that need one only sometimes. The documents in question are the core ones: the commercial invoice (81 per cent), the certificate of origin (73 per cent) and the bill of lading (69 per cent).

One respondent, a medium-sized automobile manufacturer and importer, described the problem in the survey’s comments. “Our own systems are in decent shape,” it said. “The bottleneck is what happens at the border and with the banks, where we still chase original bills of lading, LC papers and conformity certificates. When one of those is late, cargo sits and payments get held up.”

Digitally advanced firms still reach for the stamp

Most respondents place themselves in the middle, with 71 per cent rating their digital transformation “moderate”. The 23 per cent who said “high” were all large firms. Among those 11 high-rated firms, 91 per cent process more than half their trade documents digitally, yet six still need signed or stamped originals usually or always, and four need paper every time. ICC Kenya’s reading is that private investment in systems has gone about as far as it can, and that further progress depends on the law and on counterparties agreeing to accept digital documents.

Asked why they digitise at all, 83 per cent cited operational efficiency and 13 per cent business growth, which suggests most firms see software as a way to run their existing trade more cheaply.

The paper comes in at the hand-offs

Between businesses, digital trade is already routine. Some 85 per cent of respondents report digital purchase orders, and 69 per cent exchange data with partners through APIs. The paper appears where firms hand documents to banks, carriers and government agencies. Some 69 per cent of respondents have digitised their customs documentation, yet agencies still ask for paper. “The real bottleneck is everyone else,” a medium-sized clearing and forwarding agent said. “KRA and KEPHIS need to catch up digitally too, or legally recognising e-documents won’t speed anything up on the ground.” All three shipping lines in the sample say they are digitally ready, while 69 per cent of respondents still handle the bill of lading on paper. Three of the five banks surveyed always need an original.

The report sets this against conditions at Mombasa, where containerised cargo dwell time averaged 104 hours in the first half of 2025, according to the Northern Corridor Transport Observatory. The port community charter set a target of 48 hours. The survey does not measure how much of that delay is down to paperwork, and the port has had congestion troubles of its own this year.

Some of this has been promised before. In 2016 the Kenya National Chamber of Commerce and Industry launched an online portal for certificates of origin and said it would be integrated with the national electronic single window. A decade later, the single window connects 41 government agencies, according to KenTrade figures for 2024 cited in the report, yet completing the electronic certificate-of-origin link between KNCCI and KenTrade still sits on ICC Kenya’s list as a quick win.

Kenyan law excludes the documents that matter most

The legal obstacle is section 83B of the Kenya Information and Communications Act. The Act’s electronic transactions provisions do not apply to rules requiring writing or signatures for wills, negotiable instruments, or documents of title. Bills of lading are documents of title and bills of exchange are negotiable instruments, so the documents that transfer ownership of goods or a right to payment fall outside the Act’s recognition of electronic records. The same section allows the Minister to add or remove classes of transaction by order.

Respondents were close to unanimous on the remedy. Asked how much legal recognition of electronic documents would help, 46 of 48 said “a great deal”, and the other two said “somewhat”. ICC Kenya wants either an amendment to section 83B or an electronic transferable records law aligned with UNCITRAL’s Model Law on Electronic Transferable Records, using the UK’s Electronic Trade Documents Act 2023 as a common-law model.

Small firms carry the most paper with the least money

Five small firms are too few to bear much weight, but the pattern points one way: four always need paper originals, four are frequently delayed, none processes more than half its documents digitally, and all five cite cost as a barrier. Agricultural exporters feel paper’s weight most, with 87 per cent saying it is definitely holding back growth, against 65 per cent of all respondents.

Business wants the government to digitise itself first

Asked what they want from government, 85 per cent chose faster digitalisation of its own agencies, ahead of training (81 per cent) and tax incentives (71 per cent). ICC Kenya turns this into six asks for the ministry. Beyond the legal change, it wants customs, standards, port and plant-health agencies to accept electronic documents end to end, guidance for banks and insurers, a tax deduction for digitisation spending and sector skills programmes. “The government should reduce the implementation cost,” one medium-sized flower exporter told the survey.

The sixth ask brings the argument back to the farms. ICC Kenya proposes proving the case on one paperless corridor for fresh produce, combining electronic phytosanitary certificates, certificates of origin, bills of lading and invoices. The electronic phytosanitary system already works, the report says. Fresh produce is a fitting place to test the rest, because its exporters report more paper than anyone else in the survey and their cargo has less time to spare than most.

Advertisement

Related Articles

Stay Ahead of the Curve

Get exclusive insights, expert analysis, and breaking news on liquidity and risk management, delivered to your inbox

Stay Updated

Get the latest insights straight from TTP - on trade finance, treasury management, and global payments delivered to your inbox.

Join 25,000+ professionals.
Unsubscribe anytime.